Yuan Shikai held enormous power as the commander of China’s strongest army. By early 1912, the Qing dynasty was on its last legs and a republic had been declared. In that momentous year, provinces in revolt had overthrown the emperors, and a provisional republican government had been set up in Nanjing under Sun Yat-sen . In February 1912 the child‐emperor Puyi formally abdicated “in a proclamation that transferred the government to the people’s representatives,” granting Yuan Shikai full powers to organize a provisional government . Sun Yat-sen, the revolutionary leader, then resigned to let Yuan become President in hopes of national unity . A provisional constitution followed in March 1912 , promising elected institutions and basic rights. Thus the republic was born under a tenuous bargain: a Qing general at the helm, and revolutionaries watching warily. Scholars note that even at the start “the constitution [was to be] republican,” but the center of power had already shifted to Yuan . This uneasy union of northern strongman and southern revolutionaries laid the groundwork for the coming struggles.
Yuan Shikai’s Rise to the Presidency (1912)
After Sun Yat-sen stepped aside, Yuan Shikai formally became provisional President in March 1912. Although he initially enacted some modern reforms, it quickly became clear that Yuan intended to dominate the new Republic. For example, in his first year as President he adopted the Gregorian calendar, reopened the civil-service examinations, and even advocated ethnic and religious equality — reforms that won him praise both at home and abroad . Yet these progressive gestures masked Yuan’s true priorities. As one historian observes, Yuan “preferred a powerful presidency” and began consolidating power at once . He refused to join any political party and worked immediately to neutralize rival forces. His regime began dismantling the independent military units of the revolution – placing them under central control – because Yuan believed a strong, unified command was needed. Contemporaries warned that installing Yuan as President had “placed at the head of state an autocrat by temperament and training” , so the revolutionaries had only a minority in the government. In practice, Yuan’s full powers and the provisional constitution’s vague checks set the stage for a struggle over who would control China’s future.
Yuan also maneuvered politically to keep the capital in his sphere. Sun’s negotiators had insisted the capital be in Nanjing, but soon after taking office Yuan found an excuse to stay in Beijing . An orchestrated mutiny by his own troops in northern cities allowed him to cite unrest and remain in the ancient capital . In this way Yuan avoided moving the government south, retaining control over both the presidency and the major military force (the Beiyang Army). By 1913 he was firmly installed in Beijing as President, presiding over a republic that in name was new, but in practice was already under his authoritarian influence.
The Kuomintang and the First Elections (1913)
The revolutionaries in the south had promised a democratic republic. In early 1913 the new government put that promise to the test by holding China’s first nationwide elections for a National Assembly. The results were clear: the Kuomintang (Chinese Nationalist Party, or KMT) – the party of Sun Yat-sen and the Tongmenghui revolutionaries – swept the polls . Under Song Jiaoren’s leadership the KMT won a commanding majority of seats, pledging to enact a full constitutional government. Song, a gifted organizer, insisted that the new cabinet be responsible to Parliament rather than the President. He argued that the legislature should have the power to choose ministers (in line with Western parliamentary practice) and check any executive abuses . In short, Song’s platform was for genuine representative government. Many welcomed this as the republic beginning to take shape: at last the legislature would balance the presidency.
Song Jiaoren’s Assassination and the Second Revolution (1913)
These democratic hopes collapsed in a flash. On March 20, 1913 Song Jiaoren was shot dead in Shanghai as he prepared to board a train . The murder took everyone by surprise. Song had been poised to become the republic’s first Premier, symbolizing its turn toward constitutional rule. Almost at once suspicion fell on Yuan Shikai’s government. In fact, contemporary investigators discovered that the assassin had been coaxed into confessing that officials close to Yuan had arranged the killing. As one account bluntly puts it, Song was assassinated “acting on the orders of Yuan Shikai” . Though Yuan was never legally convicted, the circumstantial evidence convinced many that he saw Song’s reforms as a threat.
Furious southern provinces now rebelled, sparking what historians call the Second Revolution (summer 1913). Governors in several key provinces (including Guangdong and Jiangxi) raised troops against Yuan. But Yuan quickly turned his Beiyang Army northward. By early September 1913 his forces had crushed the revolt and recaptured the rebel capital of Nanjing . Notably, Sun Yat-sen himself fled abroad to avoid arrest . With the southern uprising crushed, Yuan emerged even stronger. In October 1913 the (still-intimidated) Parliament formally elected Yuan as China’s constitutional President . (October 10 was chosen as inauguration day to mark the anniversary of the 1911 revolution.) This victory empowered Yuan’s rule: with the KMT faction broken and its leader exiled, he no longer faced serious political competition.
From President to Dictator (1913–1914)
Once in full control, Yuan Shikai set about sidelining all rivals. He used his majority troops and loyal governors to push through measures that no earlier president could have. For example, when Parliament tried to block a huge foreign loan Yuan simply went ahead and secured the funds from foreign banks . By the end of 1913 he had taken decisive steps to eliminate the KMT from politics. In November 1913 he officially banned the Kuomintang and expelled its remaining deputies from Parliament . (Sun Yat-sen and other Nationalist leaders were forced into permanent exile.) Meanwhile, Yuan replaced Congress’s rebel governors with officers loyal to him. He even coerced legislators by lining the halls with soldiers.
Yuan’s coup de grâce came at the start of 1914. On January 10, 1914 he abruptly dissolved the National Assembly . The legislators who remained had already had their numbers gutted; now Yuan abolished the body altogether and hand-picked a new “Constitutional Council” composed of his supporters. This council drafted a so-called “Constitutional Compact” that massively expanded the President’s powers. In effect the republic’s checks and balances vanished. By this point outside observers agreed that the system was hardly a democracy at all. As Britannica bluntly concludes: “The presidency had become a dictatorship.” . From 1914 on, Yuan ruled China as a virtual one-man state.
Once firmly in office, Yuan Shikai looked every part the military strongman-president. He now wore medals and a military sash, and portraits of him spread across official buildings. His regime moved fully into autocracy. Newspapers were censored, critics were arrested, and even individual speech was tightly controlled. (Foreign observers noted that newspapers were “urged not to print any stories that might be harmful to public order.”) In Parliament Yuan’s supporters passed laws at his request. Foreign governments, meanwhile, treated him as China’s sole representative – giving him diplomatic status that earlier Qing emperors might have thought unimaginable. The small Republic that had been promised in 1912 was gone. Now, explicitly or not, Yuan was holding onto power by force.
The Hongxian Emperor: Yuan’s Ill-Fated Monarchy (1915–1916)
By late 1915, even Yuan was not satisfied with being “President-for-Life.” He decided to revive the monarchy outright. In December 1915 a body of loyal deputies (crammed into Beijing’s Great Hall) proclaimed the end of the Republic and invited Yuan to become Emperor of China. Yuan agreed and took the era name Hongxian. His announcement was brief, but shockwaves followed immediately. Many Chinese – even former supporters – were outraged. Critics pointed out that Yuan’s government had just accepted Japan’s humiliating Twenty-One Demands in 1915; his critics charged that he had traded Chinese concessions for Japanese backing of his throne . On Christmas Day 1915 the first rebellion broke out: in Yunnan province Governor Cai E openly denounced Yuan as a usurper and declared independence . Soon Guangxi and other southern provinces joined the revolt.
Faced with this sudden nationwide uprising, Yuan backed down before his enthronement. He took the crown for only 83 days. On 22–23 March 1916 he formally renounced the throne . Contemporary accounts describe how even his own generals warned him to step down. One historian notes that Yuan’s bold experiment as “Hongxian Emperor” was met with “widespread condemnation” . Ultimately, for historians the imperial interlude sealed Yuan’s reputation as an ambitious despot: he briefly overturned the revolution’s ideals and tried to turn back the clock to one-man rule. When he gave up the crown, he still retained the presidency – but the damage was done.
Death and Disunion: The Warlord EraWarlord Era Full Description:A period of total political fragmentation following the death of the first strongman president, Yuan Shikai. The central government in Beijing became a puppet regime, while real power lay in the hands of regional military commanders who fought constant civil wars for control of territory and resources. The Warlord Era represents the complete collapse of the central state. China was carved up into personal fiefdoms by rival cliques (the Anhui, Zhili, and Fengtian). Laws were replaced by martial force, and the economy was devastated by constant looting, forced conscription, and the imposition of arbitrary taxes by passing armies.
Critical Perspective:This era demonstrates the consequences of the militarization of politics. Without a unifying ideology or civilian institutions, power devolved to the lowest common denominator: violence. It also laid bare the cynical nature of foreign powers, who recognized and funded various warlords to keep China divided and weak, ensuring favorable trade conditions for themselves.
Read more Begins (1916)
Yuan Shikai never fully recovered from the stress of 1916. Politically, the country was in chaos. Under pressure from generals and provinces that had renounced his rule, Yuan considered abdicating the presidency as well. But before he could do so, his health failed. He died of illness (probably uremia) on June 6, 1916 . In his will he recommended that Vice-President Li Yuanhong succeed him – a choice surprisingly acceptable to the embittered political factions . Li assumed the presidency and the constitution was briefly restored, but Yuan’s era was over.
Yuan’s death left a monumental power vacuum. No central figure remained to hold the country together. Almost immediately, China splintered. His former generals and governors carved the nation into their own fiefs. As one commentator puts it, “Yuan’s death on 6 June 1916 created a power vacuum which was filled by military strongmen and widespread violence” . Within months, provinces were effectively independent. In the north, Beiyang generals such as Duan Qirui and Cao Kun seized power in Beijing’s name, while in the south Sun Yat-sen and his Nationalists set up a rival government in Canton (Guangzhou) . Thus began the notorious Warlord Era: a decade in which no central government could enforce order. In the end, the Republic that Yuan had helped to found – and later betrayed – collapsed into factional fighting.
Yuan Shikai’s Legacy
Historians continue to debate Yuan Shikai’s legacy, with much of the 20th-century historiography casting him as a villain and traitor who stole the revolution and led China back toward despotism. Early analyses, such as those discussed by Patrick Fuliang Shan, emphasized Yuan’s role in crushing the young democracy and transforming the presidency into a dictatorship. Works like “The legacy of Yuan Shikai, China’s disastrous first president” and revisionist scholarship cited in “Parting with a villain? Yuan Shikai in light of new research” describe how he “hijacked” the Republic, betraying both the Qing court—whom he helped overthrow—and the revolutionaries, whom he later suppressed. In this historiographical tradition, Yuan is chiefly remembered for his cynicism and ambition, overthrowing one empire only to attempt founding another.
In recent years, however, scholars have given a more nuanced assessment. Some now see Yuan as a pragmatic conservative who genuinely feared chaos. As one modern historian summarizes, “Yuan was a conservative who would have preferred to preserve the Qing Empire, [but] he was an effective administrator in challenging circumstances” . In other words, this view suggests Yuan did work on some reforms and modernization (for example, building up the Beiyang Army, reforming finance, and pursuing foreign loans), but that he was also willing to be ruthless. He believed China was not yet ready for Western-style democracy, so he clung to strongman rule.
Other historians such as Jerome Ch’en, Patrick Fuliang Shan, and authors cited in The China Project emphasize Yuan Shikai’s long-term impact on China’s political development. His decision to build a powerful personal army and appoint loyal generals to provincial posts inadvertently laid the groundwork for the warlord era, as highlighted by accounts that note he “built a private army from which many power-hungry warlords emerged to devastate the country in the 1920s”. In this interpretation, Yuan is seen as a key figure in the collapse of centralized government—whether by design or by miscalculation—since his power moves undermined national unity and effective state authority.[2][3][5][11]
Authors like Jerome Ch’en and reviews in Britannica and Wikipedia concur that Yuan’s legacy is mixed: he advanced some administrative modernization, yet his personal ambition and suppression of constitutional rule ultimately doomed the fragile republic he helped create. Most scholars agree that after his death, China’s hopes for a stable republican government collapsed, leaving the nation in the hands of rival generals for a generation—a fractured situation that many trace directly to Yuan Shikai’s tenure and decisions.
Leave a Reply to Self-Strengthening or Self-Deception? China’s First Modernization Efforts (1861–1895) – Explaining History PodcastCancel reply